American Idol 3 - (tonight: AI SPECIAL after M'sian Idol)

sokong camile sbb sore dia unik. mmg lah lately the performance was so deceiving. bak kata simon, she has another week to go... too bad, girl!

cuma kesian kat amy, walaupun tak vote for her, tapi rasanya jenifer hudson should be cut out last week. dia ni dah lah gembeng, oversinging, emotional... she should be the one last week...

apa pun.. good luck to the rest.. ishh.... tak sabor nak tunggu wednesday ngan thursday!

"bayangkanlah malam anda tanpa AMERICAN IDOL!"

dollah_bedwi

fantaS*** tu bagak nak mapus mcm dia tu bagus sangat nyanyi , tak boleh terima kritikan langsung , pas bahasa dia guna tu mcm negro getto , mmc tak educated .. harap terleluar sebab perangai taki senonoh..

biarle mcm george ke jpl ..cool ajer terima komen

Ramai jugak ye yang tak berkenan dengan attitute fantasia.....

Apa2x pun aku respect kat the contestants yang cool je terima kritikan... for eg. like Matt Rogers (walaupun dah terkeluar last 2 weeks).. kesian gak aku kat mamat ni.. Simon kalau dah kutuk dia, tak ingat2x seh... cakap... he's nauseating la.. apa la.. frankly i love his voice... but too bad he's out already....

Lagi satu JPL... aku rasa mamat ni kekadang cam confius, like not really sure what kind of performance/image to project.  bukan apa... 1st dorang suruh dia let go his personalilty...  pas tu Randy & Paula lak cakap suruh cut down on the dancing, to let his vocal do the talking....dah tu bila dia nyanyi serius dorang cakap... he's not happening.... Simon nya comments.. lagi la buat aku pening... memula cakap JPL has potentially a very.. very good voice... abis tu minggu yang kemudian nya lak cakap.. he has an odd voice... alimakatakz... kalau aku jadi JPL pun.... terblur sotong gak....konpius...

Camile lak.. aku suka gak sora dia.. unik..i think she's the odd one out among the girls... cuma deyni the thing which seems to be on a downside is her lack of confidence....

Contestants like, Fantasia (d judges are to blame also.. kalau dah mengampu minah ni.. bukan main lagi.. cam ne la dia tak naik tocang !), Latoya, George, to an extent Diana & Jasmine... so far the judges comments about them are pretty consistent....

[ Last edited by chocolate on 6-4-2004 at 09:59 AM ]

whitedove

Elton John's songs theme...

lagu2 Elton John banyak range, so maybe theme yg paling sesuai untuk semua peserta AI3...

sayangidaku

wah...best gak lagu2 'diva' elton john...

actually d comments are out on AI 3 website.. so obviously org2x kat USA, etc.. dah selamat menyaksikan the 'Elton John' theme night... aku cuma baca the judges comments for Fantasia je, coz she's the first one to sing... tapi pas tu aku tak teruskan.. coz I dun wanna spoil my mood watching it tonite.... hehe...

can't wait for tonite....:cak: :pmuka:

c-mei

Originally posted by yipun78 at 2-4-2004 11:42 AM:
Walaupun bukan favourite list, tapi "die" nie ade vokal yg tersendiri.............
yipun PALING mengharapkan yg si FANTASIA 2 keluaq cepat.............tak taulah ngape, tapi mmg TAK MINA ...

ha..ha...aku pun tak minat gak ngan dier nie tapi takderlah harap sgt dier keluar cepat coz nanti takder pesaing....tapi dier nie mmg kena control skit kelakuan dier time kena komen ngan si Samun tue..:lol

hari tue aku nengok mmg aku pun terkejut gak at bottom 3 coz Latoya ader kat situ...tapi aku rasa Amy Adam nyer performance ok...tapi apasal John Steven takder termasuk kat bottom 3....maybe mcm korang cakap fanbased kuat...

oklah even aku minat camille tapi aku rasa performance dier hari tue pun tak best...and kalau dier terkeluar lepas nie pun takper...apasallah dier suker sgt buat muker dier mcm nak nangis tue...risau plak aku nengok...

bila kiter guna viewers yg jadi juri mmg kdg2 the result a little bit shock...jgn tak ingat penah terjadi time AF dulu...cumer tue rancangan malaysiotah...tapi aku rasa AI niepun mcm dah nak samer jer ngan AF tue...lebih kpd popular dari talent...

tapi aku harap jgnlah next week the talent yg kuar...tapi kalau fantasia tue aku tak kesah...tak semestinyer kiter ader suara best org suker kiter and pikir kiter bagus cth mcm Rosma...kalau fantasia nie suker sgt lawan cakap judge ...aku rasa tak lama dier kat atas stage tue...:ah:

c-mei

Originally posted by whitedove at 7-4-2004 12:11 PM:
Elton John's songs theme...

lagu2 Elton John banyak range, so maybe theme yg paling sesuai untuk semua peserta AI3...

waa...Elton John night...tak sabar nak tengok...

msd_brit

John steven buat performance lain dari yg sebelumnya .. I like it even though judge tak suka

JPL and Chemile is the worst one for this week

The best performance for this week is .... Jennifer Hudson ... good job girl ... dia dah dapat dah control suaranya yg tinggi supaya tak over sangat .. so dia punya suara jadi sedap

What happen to Latoya .. apasal dah 2 minggu nie performance dia kurang hah ???

DARSITA

lagu lagu Elton John tak sesuai dinyanyikan oleh para peserta. Hancus!! nasiblah fantasia, jasmine dgn Josh punya perembahan okay sikit. frust betulah tengok american Idol semalam.

w|nTer^GurL

hancus? theme elton john tak best ker.. tak sabar nyer tunggu jumaat nih..
ingatkan theme ni la dorang leh tunjuk kemantapan vokal...

sayangidaku

yeker teruk...hmmmmmm. tengok website ajela.

gjoy_chester

Originally posted by msd_brit at 2004-4-8 01:11 AM:
John steven buat performance lain dari yg sebelumnya .. I like it even though judge tak suka

JPL and Chemile is the worst one for this week

The best performance for this week is .... Jenni ...

Bagi aku perfomance ok cuma die selalu bawa lagu2 slow berbanding peserta lain yang suka bawa lagu2 rancak....sebab tu nampak perfomance La To Ya tak berapa menyerlah....

Bagi aku lak, perf. paling teruk malam tu... tak lain tak bukan Camile Velasco.  Aku rasa dia ni pun dah tak lama la...mlm ni kalau dia tak masuk bottoms 3 pun aku tak tau apa nak cakap...

John Stevens.. actually i like what i saw yesterday.. for once i saw a differnet & chilled-out John.. even though i know he didn't sing it well.  Kesian gak aku nengok mamat ni kena hamput dek Simon & Randy.

JPL.. gosh.. what's happening to him ? I agree with what Randy said.. since the last couple of weeks.. he seems to be nervous & shy.. and lack the winner spirit in him.  Aku nengok dia ni macam dah give-up je...... even masa Ryan int. dia pun.. muka dia aku nengok cam sodih semacam... adui.... perf. dia aku rasa okay, even Simon pun cakap its average at best... tapi nampak macam he no longer enjoy what he did, like he normally is.  Worst comes to worst aku rasa.. he still got a few more weeks left.... he's my ultimate fav, but then i know.. if he's no longer up to mark.. he has to go....

Overall malam tu... apart from those 3.... almost all the finalists kena critise.. tak pun.. sure kena kat Simon.  George, Latoya & Jennifer are the only 3 who got thumbs up from all the 3 judges....

gjoy_chester

Originally posted by chocolate at 2004-4-8 11:36 AM:
Bagi aku lak, perf. paling teruk malam tu... tak lain tak bukan Camile Velasco.  Aku rasa dia ni pun dah tak lama la...mlm ni kalau dia tak masuk bottoms 3 pun aku tak tau apa nak cakap...

John  ...

Wa...bestnyer La ToYa dapat thumb up dari 3 judges...

kulit

POwer to the PEOPLE?

慬b]American Idol

gjoy_chester

[quote]Originally posted by kulit at 2004-4-8 12:37 PM:
POwer to the PEOPLE?

慬b]American Idol

msd_brit

Don't care ngan pendapat dia tue :gantuk:

gjoy_chester

Originally posted by msd_brit at 2004-4-8 01:09 PM:
Don't care ngan pendapat dia tue :gantuk:

Tapi pendapat Linda ni ade betulnyer gak...

camile was at her worst performance last nite. dont think she could survive tonite. john steven, was ok.. JPL, as usual, enjoyable.. latoya, hmm.. wow the crowd!

too bad camile... pack ur bag and dont turn back! u've lost ur talent....